Is Card Counting Legal?

Updated

Counting cards in your head is legal in every state in the country. It is not cheating, it is not fraud, and no statute prohibits it. What you are doing is watching cards that were dealt in the open and thinking about them. The catch is that a casino is private property, and in most of the country it can stop dealing to you or ask you to leave for any reason it likes.

The short version

These get confused constantly, so it is worth separating them.

The state does not care that you count. Gaming statutes define cheating as altering the outcome of a game or the odds of a game by physical means: marking cards, switching chips, using a device. Paying attention is none of those things. Courts have said so repeatedly.

The casino is a private business. Outside New Jersey it can decide who it deals to, and a skilled blackjack player is bad inventory. Getting shown the door is a business decision, not a punishment from the government, and it leaves nothing on your record.

What a casino can and cannot do

The usual countermeasures, roughly in order of severity:

What they generally cannot do is treat you like a thief. Gaming-crimes statutes give a licensee limited authority to detain someone on probable cause of an actual gaming crime, and counting in your head is not one. In practice, a back-off is a short and polite conversation. You color up, you take your chips to the cage, and you go.

If it happens to you: stay calm and cooperate. Argue nothing, record nothing, and leave when you are asked. Almost every counter who ends up in real trouble got there by escalating a situation that was already over.

Where the line actually is: devices

This is the part people get wrong, and it is the part with prison attached.

Nevada law makes it unlawful to use, or to possess with intent to use, any device that helps you analyze the odds of a game or keep track of the cards played. That is NRS 465.075, and a violation is a category C felony. Other gaming states have their own versions.

The statute does not care how simple the device is. A counting app on your phone at the table falls under it. So does a hidden toe-operated computer, which is what the statute was written for in the first place. The moment the count leaves your head and enters a machine, you have crossed from advantage play into a felony.

Draw the line here: the count lives in your head, or you are committing a crime. Practice with an app at home as much as you like. Never open one at the table.

Team play sits in a gray area worth knowing about. Counting as a team is not itself illegal, but signaling with electronics is a device offense, and casinos treat organized teams far more aggressively than they treat a lone player.

Why New Jersey is different

Atlantic City is the one place in the country where a casino cannot throw you out for counting, and there is a case behind that.

Ken Uston, a well-known counter, was barred from Resorts International and sued. In 1982 the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled in his favor in Uston v. Resorts International Hotel. The reasoning was jurisdictional: the Casino Control Act handed the Casino Control Commission exclusive authority over how casino games are played, so an individual casino had no power to write its own exclusion rule. Absent a valid Commission regulation, Uston kept his ordinary right of access to the blackjack tables.

Atlantic City casinos did not simply give up. What they got instead were rule countermeasures the Commission does allow: early shuffles, restrictions on mid-shoe entry, and limits on the number of hands a player can spread to. You will not be barred for counting in New Jersey. You will be shuffled at.

The charge that actually shows up: trespass

Nearly every card counter who ends up in a courtroom is there for the same reason, and it has nothing to do with counting.

Once a property has formally trespassed you, returning is criminal trespass. Casinos share images and names across properties and corporate groups, and facial recognition is now standard at the front doors of large operators. Coming back to a property that has barred you, even a year later, even to eat dinner, is a genuine criminal risk in a way that counting never was.

The rule that follows from that is simple. If you are trespassed, do not go back.

What about online?

Counting online is legal for the same reason it is legal in a pit, but it is rarely useful. Most online blackjack reshuffles after every hand, and a shoe that never runs down cannot be counted at all.

Live dealer tables use a real shoe and a real cut card, so counting is at least possible there. What limits it is the operator's terms of service, which reserve the right to restrict or close the account of anyone identified as an advantage player. That is a contract question, not a criminal one, but the practical result is the same. We go through the details in does card counting work online.

Why so many people think it is illegal

Movies, mostly. Counters get chased through parking garages on screen, and the story only works if they are doing something criminal.

The real explanation is duller. A private business is allowed to refuse service, so a legal activity can still get you removed. That gap between "not against the law" and "not allowed on the premises" is where the whole myth lives.

Who can enter a casino

In Nevada, New Jersey, and most commercial gaming states, the minimum age for a casino floor is 21. Some tribal casinos admit players at 18, and a few states set 18 for certain venues. Bring a government-issued ID and expect to show it.

Beyond age, admission is at the operator's discretion, which is where everything above comes back around.

Worth keeping straight:
• Counting in your head is legal in all fifty states.
• A device that tracks cards or odds is a felony in Nevada.
• A casino outside New Jersey may refuse to deal to you.
• Returning after a trespass notice is the charge that sticks.

This page explains how the law is generally understood and is not legal advice. If you are facing an actual dispute with a casino, talk to an attorney licensed in that state.

Our live counter is an educational and training tool about the math of the game. Use it at home, not at the table.

The chart is legal too, and it comes firstBasic strategy is nothing but arithmetic. The trainer will get it into your memory.
Open the trainer →

Keep reading

Card countingwhat it actually is Counting onlinewhere it still works How to countstart from zero

By Martin Kosek · every number on this site is computed by us, not copied.

← Back to guides